R.8

Sources and conflicts

The manual ranks the code at the tags above the documentation, uses its own recorded runs for every listing and measured number, and records 32 conflicts between its sources.

The ranks are the same as in How to read this manual. When two sources disagree, the higher one wins, and the section says so. We read every source and checked every fact on 2026-11-14. How this manual was made describes the machines and the method.

The ranked sources

RankSourceWhat the manual takes from it
1the source code of each package at its release tagevery class, parameter, default, and error text, and the reference tables
2the LangChain documentation, built from one commit of its repositorythe documented behaviour, in our own words, checked against the code and our runs
3the changelog and the release notes of each packagewhen a change came, and which package version holds it
4the capture kit, with Qwen3 4B on Ollama where a scenario needs a modelevery listing
5the lab recordings on two machines, the account run against the hosted LangSmith API, the task-suite bench, and the production service of Part 9. Their Claude rows ran through the Anthropic APIevery number in a paragraph that starts with "We measured"

GitHub issues, pull requests, and security advisories are evidence for a behaviour at the pin. The text names each one by its number, and it never presents an issue as our result. The product pages of the project have no open license. Section 1.1 states their claims in our words and sets each one beside a run.

Rank 1: the code

PackageVersionCommitUsed in
langchain1.5.0, released 2026-11-11c2f4036eevery part
langchain-core1.8.0a4b4a7b9, the same core tree as c2f4036eevery part
langgraph, with langgraph-checkpoint 4.3.2 and langgraph-prebuilt 1.1.21.2.2208a20169Part 2, Parts 4 to 6, Part 8
langgraph-checkpoint-sqlite3.1.35bd231cb by the release record. We read its code at 08a20169, which holds 3.1.3Part 2, Part 5
langgraph-checkpoint-postgres3.2.1, from the lab environmentthe langgraph repository at 08a20169Part 5, Part 9
deepagents0.7.38c858b3647.4, 7.5
langsmith0.14.1715dd2a787.6, 7.7
langgraph-api, langgraph-cli0.18.0, 0.4.43the published packages8.1
langchain-openai, langchain-anthropic, langchain-ollama1.8.0, 1.7.10, 1.1.0their own tagsPart 3, 1.2, 4.3
fastmcp, mcp4.2.0, 2.3.0the published packages7.3
fastapi, starlette, uvicorn, psycopg, opentelemetry-sdk0.162.7, 1.10.0, 0.54.0, 3.3.9, 1.45.2the published packages, from the lockfile of the servicePart 9
agent-chat-uino release and no tag, pinned to main0d21f7ff, committed 2026-11-03, with @langchain/langgraph-sdk 1.12.88.2
wcmatch12.0.1, from the lab environmentthe published package8.4
langchain-mcp-adapters0.3.2, archivedits last tag7.3, 8.5

Rank 2: the documentation

The site serves its main branch, and no tag of the docs matches a package release. We read every page at docs commit 04d4d4a of 2026-11-13. The sections cite each page by its path, and these groups of pages are the ones they use most:

PagesUsed in
the agents, models, messages, tools, and install pages of LangChainPart 1, Part 3, Part 4
structured output, the built-in middleware, custom middleware, guardrails, and human in the loopPart 4, Part 6
streaming and event streaming of LangChain and LangGraphPart 2, Part 5
checkpointers, persistence, stores, short-term and long-term memory, and fault tolerancePart 2, Part 5, Part 6
the graph API, Send and Command, the functional API, interrupts, time travel, subgraphs, and PregelPart 2, Part 6
the MCP pages, the Deep Agents overview, and the retrieval pagesPart 7
tracing, the observability quickstart, evaluation, pytest, and usage and billing of LangSmithPart 7
Agent Server, its scale guide, the CLI, double texting, the environment variables, and the standalone serverPart 1, Part 8
the release policy, the changelog, the v1 release notes, and the migration guidesPart 3, Part 8

Rank 3: releases

The changelog page and the GitHub release of each package give the version of each change. Section 8.5 uses them to date each change since 0.x.

The LangChain, LangGraph, and Python marks in the figures belong to their owners, and we use them only to identify the projects.

Ranks 4 and 5: the kit and the lab

The capture kit writes 56 files: 19 model-free, 36 recorded, and 1 sidecar. The lab holds 51 experiment folders, 48 summary files, and the bench with its own summary. The production service of Part 9 keeps its code, its raw runs, and ten summaries in one folder. The bench and the service priced each Claude call at the list prices of the Anthropic pricing page, read on 2026-11-14. How this manual was made lists each experiment with its machine and its count.

Issues and advisories

IssueWhat it reportsUsed in
langgraph #9267durability="sync" without a checkpointer raises AttributeError5.3, 8.6
langgraph #8039sync does not fix the order of put_writes and put5.3
langgraph #9185, #9240a node that raised runs again on a resume, and a request to document that durability is not exactly once5.3
langgraph #8757SqliteStore keeps vector rows after a delete5.4, 8.4
langgraph #7714a measured token cost of checkpoints, closed because checkpoints are not sent to the model5.5
langchain #38352orphan tool messages after a summary, which our runs did not reproduce5.5
langgraph #8388, #8184, #8826, #8938values that the serializer does not rebuild, and plaintext rows under encryption5.6
langchain #38484, #38533a v3 consumer gets the final answer in one burst, and a closed pull request that changed create_agent and not the projection code5.1, 2.5
langgraph #9712after InvalidUpdateError, a saved thread raises on every read until a reducer is deployed, which we reported6.1, 2.2, 8.6
langchain #40492a middleware jump can skip a batched review4.5, 6.5, 8.4
langchain #33787, langgraph #9106an edit that ran the old call, and a resume that ran a finished branch, which did not reproduce6.5
langchain #40531, langgraph #7988tool calls with no id, and two tools with one name3.4
langchain #40688a tool retry runs a tool that is not idempotent again4.7
langgraph #8517ToolNode under ainvoke ignores max_concurrency4.1
langchain #40471an MCP error result loses its structuredContent7.3
langchain #41870tracing_context(enabled="local") sends the runs of LangChain code, which we reported7.6, 7.7
langsmith-python #106evaluate(upload_results=False) prints %s and gives three names to one call, which we reported7.7
langsmith-python #107with tracking on, every log_* call of the pytest plugin raises unless LANGSMITH_TRACING=true, which we reported7.7

Section 8.4 gives the table of security advisories, with the range of each one and our result at the pin.

The conflict register

Each row is one disagreement between two sources. The choice is what this manual tells you to do, and the last column says what the project had done by 2026-11-14.

IdThe sources sayThe manual followsSectionsUpstream
D2The docstring of GenericFakeChatModel says that it does not stream, and the unit testing page says that it does. The code streams text and drops tool calls.the code: test streaming against a real model, or a fake that streams tool calls8.6no issue found
D3The example in the ToolRuntime docstring calls stream_writer.write. The type is a plain callable.the code: call runtime.stream_writer(value)3.4not checked
D4StreamMode and the streaming page list seven modes. The loop also accepts tools.the code and the capture: tools is a mode5.1, R.3not checked
D6durability="sync" is a documented mode. Without a checkpointer it raises AttributeError.the run: use sync only with a checkpointer5.3issue #9267 open at the pin. Fix PR #9268 closed without a merge
D8The docstring of create_deep_agent names execute and not delete. The default backend binds delete and no execute.the capture: delete is a default tool7.4not checked
D101The install page and the release policy say Python 3.10, and the policy changes the floor only in a major release. langchain 1.5.0 needs 3.11.the package metadata: Python 3.11 or later3.1, 8.5open at docs 04d4d4a
D102A batched example edits a call to a new tool name. The per-call text and the 1.4.6 changelog say that an edit keeps the tool.the lab: batched mode allows the switch, and per-call mode refuses it6.5open
D104The agents page calls messages append only. The memory page removes messages with RemoveMessage.the code of add_messages: append, replace by id, and remove6.1open
D105The graph API page gives 10,007, and 10,000 for older versions. The server docs give 10011. Old advice gives 25.the code and the runs: 10007 for a graph, 9999 for create_agent, 10007 under langgraph dev6.8, 8.1, R.5open
D106The stores page links InMemoryStore to a class in langchain_core.stores. Its code imports langgraph.store.memory.the code: import from langgraph.store.memory5.4, R.4open
D107Both v1 release pages link create_react_agent to the function of the same name in langchain-classic.the code: two functions share the name8.5open
D108A LangSmith FAQ table calls checkpointers community code and streaming basic.the current pages and the code8.5open
D109The Deep Agents overview names planning as a default. The 0.7.0 changelog makes it opt in.the changelog and the capture: add TodoListMiddleware7.4, 8.5open
D111The product page says that tracing never affects your application. The tracing docs say that LANGCHAIN_CALLBACKS_BACKGROUND=false makes callbacks wait. No code at the pin reads that variable.the lab and the code: about 6 ms per agent run on Qwen3 4B against the hosted API, and no effect from the variable at the pin7.6open at docs 04d4d4a
D113The prompt hub page teaches the hub through langchain_classic.the LangSmith client methods that the same page recommends7.7, 8.5open
D114A tracing page leads with an LCEL chain.trace a create_agent agent8.5open
D116The local server page prints the old name LangGraph Studio.the current names: LangSmith Studio and Agent Server8.5open
D117The v1 release page has a frozen list of providers with content blocks, and no langchain.mcp.the changelog and the current pages8.5open
D118The checkpointers page says that a thread must be created before a run. That rule belongs to Agent Server.the code: the first checkpoint creates the thread5.2open
D119The checkpointers page does not name the default durability. The Agent Server pages say async.the code: async5.3open
D121The structured output page says that an agent uses tool calling when the model has no structured output, for ProviderStrategy too.the code: an explicit strategy stays as it is4.2open
D123The help text of langgraph dev gives 10 jobs per worker. The code uses 1. The docs give 1 for Python and 10 for JS.the code and the run: 18.1open
D124The streaming page says that tasks mode needs a checkpointer. The kit got chunks from tasks and debug without one.the capture5.1not checked
D130The built-in middleware page lists 22 classes. langchain has 19, and three come from deepagents.the code: 19 in langchain4.6open
D131The backends page says that virtual_mode defaults to False. The code sets it to True.the code and the run: a backend built with no virtual_mode gave the same 28 results as virtual_mode=True8.4not checked
D132The permissions page says that an allow rule on /workspace/**, placed first, matches .env, so a later deny never fires.the run: /workspace/** does not match a dot name, so both orders denied /workspace/.env and both let /.env through8.4not checked
D133The permissions examples "Deny all access", "Read-only", and "Isolate to a workspace directory" use /**.the run: /** skips dot names, so .env, .git, and .bashrc stay readable or writable, and the isolate list also denies ls of /workspace8.4not checked
D134The backends page names a legacy default that reads assistant_id, and says a namespace is required from v0.5.0.the code and the run: at 0.7.38 the namespace is required, and StoreBackend(store=s) raised TypeError5.4not checked
D135The composite backend examples pass namespace=lambda _rt: ("memories",).the run: that factory is one namespace for every user, so build it from the user id5.4, 8.4not checked
D136The backends page allows a period in a namespace label and suggests the user identity as a label. The store refuses a period with InvalidNamespaceError.the run: an email address as a label fails on write, so map it to a label without a period5.4not checked
D137The models page of Deep Agents shows an overall score of 0.18 for openai:gpt-5.4 and 0.26 for anthropic:claude-opus-4-6.the page itself: each overall score equals the tool use score of its row, while the file operations, retrieval, and summarization cells are 0.92 to 1.00, and each row mixes cells from 3 CI runs1.2no upstream item
D209Users report errors, with no switch to tool calling, from an explicit ProviderStrategy on Bedrock and Ollama. The docs say that it switches.the code and the lab: no switch4.2issue langchain #35119
D211A web page says that LangGraph streaming adds 100 to 300 ms to the first token, with no method.the lab: under 3.5 ms at the median on Qwen3 4B5.1no upstream item

The ids are not continuous. The research kept one range of ids for each kind of source. D1 to D17 are the code, and D101 to D137 are the docs. D201 to D211 are posts and issues. This register holds every id that a section cites.

LangChain (Python): langchain, langchain-core, langgraph, deepagents, langsmith 1.5.0 · c2f4036 · 2026-11-11 · Edition 2026.11